Key Points
- South Korea's Supreme Court overturned a 7-year appellate sentence for an 81-year-old shaman who tied her niece over burning charcoal for three hours, ruling the act constitutes murder.
- The ruling clarifies that claiming a ritual was meant to 'expel evil spirits' cannot erase conditional intent to kill when the act is plainly life-threatening and cruel.
- The court highlighted that traditional Korean shamanic practices like gut and jesa involve minimum safety standards, unlike the unprecedented torture used in this fatal ritual.
Summary South Korea's Supreme Court has overturned a lower court's decision in a chilling murder case involving a fatal shamanic exorcism, ruling that an 81-year-old shaman and her accomplices acted with conditional intent to kill when subjecting her niece to extreme heat from burning charcoal.
The tragedy unfolded in September 2024 at a restaurant in Bupyeong-gu, Incheon. When the victim, a woman in her 30s referred to as Ms. A, announced her plans to quit working at the restaurant and move to Ulleungdo Island to live with her parents, the shaman, surnamed Sim, claimed that an evil spirit possessed Ms. A and harbored intentions of killing her mother. Sim insisted on conducting an exorcism ritual using charcoal heat to banish the demon. With the assistance of her adult children, followers, and other relatives, Sim strapped Ms. A face-down onto an improvised iron rack and repeatedly shoveled hot, burning coals into a basin placed directly beneath her. Despite the victim losing consciousness multiple times during the three-hour ordeal, the group continued the ritual. After Ms. A lost consciousness completely, the perpetrators dismantled the setup and waited two hours before calling emergency services, falsely claiming that the victim had accidentally collapsed onto burning charcoal. Ms. A died two days later from multiple organ failure caused by severe burns.
The legal journey of the case sparked intense public debate across South Korea. While the initial district court sentenced Sim to life imprisonment for murder, the Seoul High Court dramatically reduced her sentence on appeal to just seven years, acquitting her of murder and applying bodily injury resulting in death (*sanghae-chisa*). The appellate court argued that murder requires proof of willful negligence or conditional intent (*mipiljeok go-ui*—knowing an action could likely result in death and accepting that outcome). It cited the participants' devout belief in Sim’s 40-year spiritual career and argued that they lacked deliberate intent to kill.
However, the Supreme Court firmly rejected this reasoning, sending the case back for retrial with murder charges reinstated. The highest bench ruled that a subjective spiritual belief does not negate the obvious, objective danger to life. Pointing out that traditional Korean shamanic practices (*gut* or *jesa*) prioritize the subject's safety, the justices noted that tying someone over burning charcoal was extraordinarily cruel, bizarre, and entirely unprecedented even in Sim’s four-decade career. The court concluded that an exorcist's stated intent to cast out a demon and the simultaneous awareness that the victim could die are not mutually exclusive, establishing that spiritual justifications cannot shield perpetrators from murder charges when life-threatening danger is plainly evident.
Sponsored · Ad