K-Pop Yonhap News Culture · 2026-11-06

HYBE and ADOR Rebut Report Alleging NewJeans Signed 'Unprecedentedly Restrictive' Contracts

Key Points
  • The New York Times reported that NewJeans signed contracts as teenage trainees lacking standard protections for minors, including sleep and education guarantees.
  • HYBE and ADOR issued an immediate rebuttal, stating the agreements were reached after extensive discussions and contained clauses safeguarding human rights.
  • Former ADOR CEO Min Hee-jin countered HYBE's claims, arguing that HYBE's corporate legal team was responsible for drafting the contracts in question.
Summary A fresh controversy has erupted over NewJeans' trainee and artist contracts following an investigative report by The New York Times, reigniting intense scrutiny over K-pop agency practices and artist welfare. According to the report, a confidential contract signed while the members were teenage trainees omitted key protections outlined in the South Korean government’s standard entertainment contract, such as guaranteed rights to sleep, education, and rest for minor entertainers. Group affiliates cited grueling training sessions stretching until 2:00 AM under video surveillance, with four out of the five members ultimately dropping out of regular schooling. The report also highlighted stringent behavioral constraints—including prohibitions on dating, slacking in self-discipline, and causing discord with the company—alongside mandatory reimbursement obligations for cosmetic procedures and perpetual label rights over the members’ likenesses and voices, even in potential AI clones. Legal observers noted that the level of restriction on artist autonomy was unusually severe compared to contemporary major label agreements. In response, parent company HYBE and subsidiary ADOR released a detailed rebuttal, firmly denying accusations of mistreatment. They asserted that the contracts were finalized in April 2022 after more than three months of extensive negotiations with the members, their parents, and independent legal representatives. The agencies emphasized that human rights provisions and a separate supplementary agreement protecting minors were in place to ensure sleep and educational rights, while surveillance cameras in common areas were strictly for safety. They also pointed out that former ADOR CEO Min Hee-jin and her team directed the contract finalization. However, Min's representatives countered the same day, claiming HYBE's central legal team authored the draft and held ultimate approval power, accusing the parent company of shifting responsibility. This clash underscores the recurring friction within the K-pop industry surrounding standard government-issued artist contracts versus specialized proprietary clauses. As K-pop has evolved into a global economic powerhouse, South Korea's Fair Trade Commission and Ministry of Culture have increasingly promoted standardized contracts to curb historic 'slave contract' abuses. Nevertheless, high-stakes corporate investments and competitive trainee systems continue to test the boundaries between rigorous professional preparation and the basic labor rights of young trainees.
Sponsored · Ad