K-Pop Yonhap News Entertainment · 2026-10-13

Police Refer Ex-ADOR CEO Min Hee-jin to Prosecution Over ILLIT Plagiarism Claims

Key Points
  • Police have referred former ADOR head Min Hee-jin and two former vice presidents to prosecution on defamation and obstruction of business charges for claiming ILLIT plagiarized NewJeans.
  • The decision aligns with previous court rulings which determined that creative concepts cannot easily claim exclusive IP protection and found no clear evidence of intentional copying.
  • The case marks a critical moment in K-pop concerning where the legal boundaries lie between creative concept inspiration and actionable defamation.
Summary The fierce corporate and creative battle within K-pop giant HYBE has reached a major legal turning point. Min Hee-jin, the former CEO of ADOR and creative mastermind behind the sensational girl group NewJeans, has been officially referred to the prosecution by police on charges of defamation and obstruction of business. According to Seoul’s Yongsan Police Station, Min was referred along with two former ADOR vice presidents on October 1. Police determined that Min circulated false claims with malicious intent to disparage HYBE and Belift Lab, the subsidiary label managing rookie girl group ILLIT. The charges trace back to April 2024, when Min held an explosive, emergency press conference claiming that ILLIT had blatant "copied" NewJeans across their audition posters, traditional hanbok pictorial concepts, debut rollout strategies, and stage choreography. Belift Lab filed a criminal complaint shortly after, condemning what it called reckless speculation that unfairly degraded the achievements and hard work of their new artists and staff. This development holds massive significance for global K-pop fans who watched the multi-label dispute erupt in public view. In the hyper-competitive K-pop industry, visual identity, overarching concepts, and distinct artistic styling are central to an agency's branding. However, South Korean legal authorities have drawn a firm line between artistic similarity and unlawful infringement. Police noted that their referral aligns directly with previous court decisions rejecting plagiarism claims. In a prior court ruling regarding an injunction over agency status, the bench observed that ILLIT's aesthetic could not be deemed plagiarism and underscored that a creative concept itself remains too ambiguous to qualify for exclusive intellectual property protection. Later, in the main lawsuit confirming the validity of NewJeans' exclusive contracts, the court recognized minor aesthetic similarities between the groups' promotional pictorials and planning proposals, yet ruled there was insufficient evidence to prove intentional duplication. With the matter now in the hands of prosecutors, this case marks a critical benchmark for how intellectual property boundaries, executive conduct, and corporate defamation are handled in modern K-pop.
Sponsored · Ad