K-Pop Yonhap News Entertainment · 2026-11-13

Court Dismisses HYBE Labels' Damages Lawsuits Against Former ADOR CEO Min Hee-jin

Key Points
  • The Seoul Western District Court ruled against HYBE sub-labels BELIFT LAB and Source Music in their combined multi-billion KRW damages lawsuits against former ADOR CEO Min Hee-jin.
  • The court judged that Min's plagiarism claims regarding girl group ILLIT copying NewJeans constituted subjective opinion protected by free expression rather than actionable false defamation.
  • While Min condemned the suits as abusive corporate litigation, both BELIFT LAB and Source Music announced immediate appeals to contest the verdict in higher court.
Summary In a landmark ruling that marks a major turning point in South Korea's most scrutinized entertainment feud, the Seoul Western District Court dismissed multi-million dollar defamation and damages lawsuits filed by HYBE sub-labels BELIFT LAB and Source Music against former ADOR CEO Min Hee-jin. The legal battle originated in April 2024, when Min held an explosive press conference accusing BELIFT LAB's rookie girl group ILLIT of copying the distinct aesthetic, choreography, hair, makeup, and creative concept of ADOR’s flagship group, NewJeans. The court rejected BELIFT LAB’s 2 billion KRW (approx. $1.5 million) lawsuit, ruling that Min's remarks alleging ILLIT had plagiarized NewJeans constituted personal and subjective opinions rather than statements of verifiable facts. Furthermore, the bench determined that even if perceived as statements of fact, the comments were protected under freedom of expression given the immense public and social interest surrounding the K-pop industry. The court simultaneously dismissed Min’s 5 billion KRW counter-suit against BELIFT LAB, ruling that both parties must bear their respective legal costs. In a related suit, Source Music—another HYBE-affiliated label managing girl group LE SSERAFIM—also lost its 500 million KRW damages claim against Min. Source Music had challenged Min’s claims regarding NewJeans' debut trajectory and her accusations that Source Music neglected the members during their trainee days. The judiciary ruled that Min’s statements did not constitute false factual assertions, emphasizing that even if they affected Source Music's social reputation, the statements were made in the public interest and carried no illegality. This verdict represents a crucial moment for freedom of commentary and corporate rivalry in K-pop. Min's team welcomed the ruling, calling it a common-sense judgment against "strategic lawsuits against public participation" (SLAPP) aimed at suppressing critique. Meanwhile, both BELIFT LAB and Source Music strongly protested the outcome and announced immediate appeals, arguing that dismissing allegations of creative theft as mere "rhetorical expression" leaves creators vulnerable and harms trust across idol training labels.
Sponsored · Ad