Key Points
- An honorary professor at Waseda University sparked controversy by claiming South Korea should return colonial-era Japanese assets because Korea is now richer than Japan.
- The remarks provoked intense backlash in South Korea as the professor equated imperial wartime atrocities with post-war asset redistribution by the U.S. military.
- Critics noted the professor's claims directly clash with the 1965 bilateral agreement, which both nations agreed resolved reciprocal property claims.
Summary A controversial statement made by a Japanese academic has ignited fierce public backlash across South Korea, reigniting deep-seated historical tensions rooted in the colonial era. Tetsuo Arima, an honorary professor at Waseda University known for previously denying the forced mobilization of Korean 'comfort women,' sparked outrage after taking to social media to argue that South Korea should return assets left behind by Japan following World War II because the country has become wealthier than Japan.
On October 13, Arima posted on social media claiming that after the war, properties and assets owned by the Japanese state and Japanese individuals in the Korean Peninsula were redistributed free of charge to local Koreans by the U.S. military government. He argued that this disposition violated international law, asserting that property rights should not be infringed upon due to war. Citing the San Francisco Peace Treaty and the 1965 normalization treaty between South Korea and Japan, Arima suggested that because South Korea is now wealthier than Japan, a new bilateral agreement should be signed to return these colonial-era 'vested assets' (gwisok jaesan) to Japanese hands.
As public outrage mounted, Arima doubled down in subsequent posts. He maintained that he was well aware of the existing 1965 agreement and was specifically proposing a new treaty, claiming that the U.S. military government acted illegally when disposing of Japanese property without the owners' consent. Furthermore, he compared the issue directly to the ongoing legal and diplomatic disputes regarding South Korean victims of forced labor and sexual slavery, stating that since Koreans continue to demand compensation from Japan despite past bilateral agreements, Japanese citizens should likewise be allowed to demand the return of their 'unfairly seized' properties.
However, critics and legal observers point out that Arima's claims directly contradict the explicit terms of the 1965 Treaty on Basic Relations and its accompanying Claims Agreement. Under the 1965 pact, both nations formally confirmed that all issues regarding property, rights, interests, and claims between the two signatory states and their nationals were settled 'completely and finally.' Ironically, the Japanese government has repeatedly cited this exact clause as its official justification to deny further direct compensation to Korean victims of forced mobilization and wartime atrocities. South Korean netizens reacted with disbelief and fury, criticizing the professor for attempting to distort historical facts and ignoring the brutal realities of imperial colonization.
Netizen Reactions Translated
An absurd argument that completely ignores the history of colonial rule.
He needs to go back and study history properly.
Sponsored · Ad