Key Points
- The Seoul Western District Court dismissed Belift Lab's 2 billion won damages lawsuit against former ADOR CEO Min Hee-jin, ruling that her claims of ILLIT copying NewJeans were protected expressions o
- The ruling is a significant development in the high-stakes feud between HYBE's sub-labels and Min Hee-jin, as the court also threw out a separate 500 million won lawsuit filed by Source Music regardin
- The decision highlights ongoing industry-wide debates over creative originality, intellectual property, and multi-label dynamics within major K-pop entertainment corporations.
Summary A South Korean civil court has dismissed a multi-million-dollar defamation lawsuit filed by Belift Lab against Min Hee-jin, the former CEO of ADOR and creative mastermind behind the mega-hit girl group NewJeans.
On November 13, the 12th Civil Division of the Seoul Western District Court ruled entirely against Belift Lab—a subsidiary label under K-pop giant HYBE—in its 2 billion won (roughly $1.4 million) damages suit targeting Min. Belift Lab, which manages rookie girl group ILLIT, had accused Min of defamation after she held a fiery April 2024 press conference alleging that ILLIT copied NewJeans across hair, makeup, style, and choreography. The court concluded that Min’s allegations constituted an expression of personal opinion rather than an assertion of objective fact. The judge further noted that even if treated as factual claims, her statements fell within the protected scope of freedom of expression given the immense public interest surrounding the industry dispute. The court also dismissed Min's 5 billion won counterclaim against Belift Lab, directing each side to bear their own legal costs.
In a related victory for the former executive, the court also threw out a separate 500 million won lawsuit brought against Min by Source Music, another HYBE subsidiary. Source Music had sued Min over her claims that the agency neglected NewJeans members during their trainee days prior to their debut. The bench determined that Min's statements could not be deemed false facts, adding that even if the comments had lowered Source Music's public reputation, they served the public interest and carried no legal illegality.
This legal confrontation strikes at the heart of the intense internal power struggle between HYBE and Min Hee-jin that has captivated the global K-pop fandom. The battle has spotlighted tensions within multi-label entertainment conglomerates, where sister labels share resources while competing for market dominance, as well as broader debates about artistic originality versus corporate formulas in the fast-moving idol industry. While Min has prevailed in these civil lawsuits, the legal saga is far from over: she was separately referred to the prosecution on criminal charges of defamation and business obstruction in October following formal complaints.
Sponsored · Ad