Key Points
- The Korean edition of anthropologist Webb Keane's book 'Animals, AI, God' examines how humans form moral and emotional bonds with non-human entities ranging from animals to artificial intelligence.
- The author notes that AI mimics human linguistic patterns much like shamans or actors, creating a supernatural impression while raising urgent questions about machine accountability.
- The work argues that AI only appears godlike because humans treat it as such, emphasizing that ethical machines must remain answerable to human oversight.
Summary How should humanity live alongside artificial intelligence, and what moral boundaries apply to beings that aren't human? A newly translated book published in South Korea, 'Animals, AI, God' (동물, AI, 신) by Webb Keane, an anthropology professor at the University of Michigan, tackles these pressing questions through a fascinating anthropological lens.
Rather than treating AI ethics purely as a futuristic conundrum of computing and code, Keane demonstrates that humanity has a long and deeply established history of coexisting with non-human entities. Drawing on cross-cultural field research and historical examples, the work spans from beloved house pets and livestock like cows and chickens to spiritual entities such as ghosts and shamans, extending all the way to modern cybernetic avatars and AI chatbots. For instance, in India, animal rights activists caress dying cows acknowledging their capacity for suffering, while devout Jains exercise extreme vigilance even while breathing to avoid harming microscopic organisms. Meanwhile, contemporary instances show humans forming intense romantic bonds with chatbots or insisting that AI companions possess unique personalities deserving of dignity and respect.
Keane argues that the sense of uncanny intelligence surrounding generative AI has cultural precedents. He compares the aura of modern AI systems to stage actors, fortune tellers, and possessed shamans (mudang) in traditional spiritual practices. Much like shamans channeling spirits, AI operates by tapping into the inherent conversational patterns, social scripts, and expressive possibilities found in ordinary human interaction. It appears magical or supernatural precisely because it reflects our own communicative behaviors back at us.
Addressing anxieties about AI surpassing its creators, the book draws a parallel to Frankenstein, cautioning against cyborg entities that 'forget their place' as the boundaries between machine and human blur. Crucially, Keane emphasizes that for an artificial intelligence to function as a truly 'moral machine,' it must possess the ability to account for and explain how and why its decisions are made. Furthermore, while AI might appear godlike because it does not die and often exceeds human comprehension, it is not an independent deity: AI acts like a god only because humans treat it like one, and its capabilities are entirely grounded in human collaboration and creation.
Sponsored · Ad