Key Points
- Wonju City suspended its Chiaksan cable car project after feasibility studies showed a Profitability Index (PI) of 0.65 to 0.68, below the 1.0 threshold.
- The move has renewed scrutiny of Yangyang County's Seoraksan Osaek cable car, which has a similar 0.65 PI while its projected cost jumped by 62.1 billion won to 179.3 billion won and its opening was p
- The contrasting choices highlight a broader Korean debate over whether long-sought regional tourism projects justify heavy upfront public investment and potential long-term local debt.
Summary A decision by Wonju City in Gangwon Province to shelve its planned Chiaksan Mountain cable car has reignited a fierce national debate over another high-profile project: the Osaek cable car at Seoraksan National Park in neighboring Yangyang County. Both projects share a nearly identical Profitability Index (PI) of around 0.65—well below the 1.0 benchmark typically used to justify public infrastructure—yet the two local governments are drawing opposite conclusions.
On November 17, Wonju City announced it would suspend follow-up work on three candidate routes for the Chiaksan cable car after feasibility studies showed PI scores between 0.65 and 0.68. With estimated construction costs of 75 billion to 78.5 billion won and projected annual ridership of about 580,000, officials concluded that long-term visitor declines, high upfront capital, and permitting hurdles outweighed the prospect of an operating surplus. Instead, Wonju plans to focus on existing tourism assets, such as seasonal Chiaksan tourism weeks, rather than heavy new construction.
In contrast, Yangyang County insists that a 0.65 PI should not derail the Seoraksan Osaek cable car. Local officials argue that initial construction payback must be separated from annual operating balance, which they expect to remain in the black, and emphasize long-term tourism spillover for the regional economy. However, changing project conditions have pushed the Osaek cable car's estimated total cost up by 62.1 billion won—from 117.2 billion won in late 2022 to 179.3 billion won—while its target completion has been delayed to 2030, with commercial operations slated for 2031.
For international readers, the clash highlights a recurring tension in South Korea's regional development: the desire of rural counties to boost tourism through landmark attractions versus environmental preservation and fiscal reality. In Korea, projects like the Osaek cable car are often described as a "resident wish project" (*sukwon saeop*)—a long-sought local initiative, in this case spanning more than 40 years, backed by the Yangyang County Council as a vital growth engine.
Environmental groups, including the Citizens' Action to Protect Seoraksan National Park, are seizing on Wonju's decision to demand a full economic reassessment of Osaek. They point out that while Osaek's projected first-year ridership of 640,000 is similar to Chiaksan's 580,000, its total price tag is more than double that of Chiaksan's individual routes. Critics warn that if Yangyang County must shoulder additional local funding, the project could become a long-term financial burden, turning the two Gangwon neighbors into a test case for how South Korea evaluates large-scale tourism infrastructure.
Sponsored · Ad