Key Points
- A government report revealed that 8.1% of SCI-level papers published in 2025 by researchers at South Korea's state-funded institutes appeared in journals from publishers under scrutiny for questionabl
- The rate exceeds the global average of 6.8%, reflecting ongoing debate in Korea despite dropping significantly from a 2021 peak of 21.7%.
- Surveys showed that while over 97% of researchers were aware of questionable journals, structural pressures for short-term quantitative output strongly drove publication in fast-turnaround open-access
Summary In South Korea, government-funded research institutes—commonly referred to in Korean as *churyeon-yeon* (출연연)—form the backbone of the nation's ambitious scientific, technological, and industrial innovation. However, a newly released report by the National Research Council of Science & Technology (NST) has brought renewed scrutiny to the integrity and pressures surrounding the country's academic publishing ecosystem. According to the study, roughly 8.1 out of every 100 Science Citation Index (SCI)-level papers authored by researchers at 23 state-funded institutes in 2025 were published in journals suspected of substandard or questionable review practices.
While this 8.1% rate is lower than the figures recorded across South Korean domestic universities (12.2%) and all domestic research combined (11.7%), it notably surpasses the global average of 6.8%. The report specifically scrutinized publications produced under controversial open-access houses often debated within the scientific community, identifying MDPI, Frontiers, and Hindawi as questionable publishers for the purpose of the study. Authors of the report were careful to note, however, that appearing in these journals does not inherently invalidate an individual paper's scientific merit.
Looking at longitudinal trends across the 2015–2025 period, the overall proportion of questionable journal publications among state institute researchers stood at 11.3%, having surged from 6.6% between 2015 and 2019 to 15.1% between 2020 and 2025. The phenomenon peaked sharply in 2021 at 21.7% before descending rapidly to 8.1% by 2025. Wide institutional and disciplinary disparities also persist: while one institute saw 34.3% of its papers (1,042 out of 3,041) appear in questionable venues, another recorded a rate as low as 3.8%. High-risk disciplines clustered predominantly around pharmacy, medicine, agriculture, fisheries, and public health.
The findings illuminate the intense institutional culture and performance metrics governing South Korean academia. A survey of the institute researchers revealed that awareness and formal education were already exceptionally high—97.3% knew about questionable journals and 85% had undergone preventive training. Yet, such training showed no statistical link to lower publication rates. Instead, researchers facing immense pressure for rapid, short-term evaluations and quantitative output, paired with favorable views toward rapid-turnaround open-access journals, were significantly more prone to publishing in questionable venues. The report underscores that systemic reforms to academic performance evaluations, rather than individual compliance training, remain essential to safeguarding research standards.
Sponsored · Ad