Culture & Life Yonhap News Culture · 15h ago

Korean Churches Urged to Embrace 'Common Sense' and Democracy to End Bitter Internal Feuds

Key Points
  • Legal and theological experts held a seminar in Seoul calling for democratic reforms to curb ongoing internal disputes in South Korean churches.
Summary South Korean legal and religious scholars are calling for sweeping governance reforms inside the nation's Protestant churches, arguing that a lack of democratic oversight and transparency has fueled an unprecedented wave of internal disputes. At an academic seminar hosted on November 20 at Sarang Church in southern Seoul by the Korea Society of Church Law and the Christian Conciliation & Arbitration Center, experts examined why conflicts over leadership transitions, church finances, and real estate assets have become so frequent—and why they so often spill into secular courts. Professor Emeritus Seo Heon-je of Chung-Ang University, who chairs the Korea Society of Church Law, noted a striking paradox: despite South Korea's famously fervent Christian congregations, internal church disputes are remarkably common. Rather than resolving disagreements through biblical principles or denominational channels, factions frequently take their battles to civil courts, resulting in public spectacles that damage the church's credibility. To prevent such escalations, Seo urged congregations to establish clear church bylaws (정관) in advance and to restore trust in denominational church courts by improving their fairness, professionalism, and transparency. Professor Cho Sung-don of the Practical Theological Graduate University offered an even sharper diagnosis, describing the frequency and intensity of South Korean church conflicts as virtually unmatched in global church history. Crucially, he pointed out that these battles are rarely about theology or doctrine. Instead, they overwhelmingly stem from clashes over pastoral succession, arbitrary financial management, monopolized administration, and competing interests in valuable church real estate. In South Korea, where megachurches and rapid urban growth have turned many congregations into major property and financial stakeholders, the concentration of power in a single senior pastor (담임목사) or a small board of elders (당회, *danghoe*) has long been a flashpoint. Cho argued that churches must dismantle these monopolies by institutionalizing democratic deliberation structures where lay members (*pyeongsindo*) participate on equal footing. He called on churches to abandon "unreasonable practices and shortcuts" once justified in the name of faith, and instead adopt moral and procedural standards higher than those of secular society—transforming into "churches where common sense prevails." Legal practitioners at the seminar echoed the need for both cultural and structural change. Attorney Baek Hyun-ki, head of the Church Law Center at Logos Law Firm, emphasized fostering a community culture rooted in love, forgiveness, humility, and service, alongside stronger ethical accountability for pastors, updated denominational constitutions, and proper separation of powers. Meanwhile, Attorney Moon Yong-ho, director of the Christian Conciliation & Arbitration Center, advocated for "relational mediation"—an approach focused on mutual recognition and empowerment to repair broken community ties rather than simply declaring a legal winner.
Sponsored · Ad