Culture & Life Yonhap News Culture · 17h ago

Redevelopment Across From Seoul's UNESCO-Listed Jongmyo Shrine Stalled After Heritage Plan Rejected

Key Points
  • The National Heritage Committee unanimously rejected the buried-heritage preservation plan for Sewoon District 4, halting any construction on the redevelopment site.
  • The decision deepens a public clash between Korea Heritage Service Commissioner Heo Min and Seoul Mayor Oh Se-hoon over project delays and building height limits.
  • Located across from Jongmyo Shrine—a 1995 UNESCO World Heritage site housing Joseon royal ancestral tablets—the area is subject to strict rules to protect its historical landscape.
Summary A major urban redevelopment project in central Seoul has hit a decisive roadblock after South Korea's National Heritage Committee voted unanimously to reject a preservation plan for archaeological relics found at the site. On November 20, the Korea Heritage Service announced that its buried-heritage subcommittee had turned down the preservation proposal for Sewoon District 4, a redevelopment zone located directly across from Jongmyo Shrine. The decision brings an end to nearly three years of deliberations that began in January 2024. According to the committee, all nine members present at the November 18 meeting agreed that the submitted plan fell short of basic preservation standards. Specifically, the proposal failed to adequately reflect the principle of preserving relics in their original locations and did not sufficiently account for the historical and cultural identity of the surrounding area. The committee noted that the plan lacked a proper strategy to represent the historical spatial structure of Hanyangdoseong—the old walled city of Seoul—including the positioning of excavated ruins, their relationships to one another, and the layout of historic roads and drainage systems. Under South Korea's Act on Protection and Inspection of Buried Cultural Heritage, no construction can proceed on a site where significant relics have been discovered until the committee approves a preservation plan and the head of the Korea Heritage Service formally signs off on the excavation. As a result, the project developer, Seoul Housing & Communities Corporation (SH), must now go back to the drawing board and submit a new preservation proposal. The ruling has also sharpened a public dispute between the central heritage agency and the Seoul Metropolitan Government. Korea Heritage Service Commissioner Heo Min took to social media to defend the committee's independent judgment, stating that the rejection was caused by an inadequate preservation plan rather than shifting regulatory standards. Heo pushed back against Seoul Mayor Oh Se-hoon's accusations of administrative overreach, pointing out that SH waited two years and seven months—until August of this year—to apply for a re-evaluation after the initial review in January 2024. According to Heo, any financial burden borne by local residents due to delays lies with the city government and SH for dragging their feet. At the heart of the controversy is the delicate balance between modernizing downtown Seoul and protecting Jongmyo Shrine, a Confucian royal ancestral shrine designated as a UNESCO World Heritage site in 1995. Jongmyo houses the spirit tablets of the kings and queens of the Joseon Dynasty (1392–1910) and the Korean Empire, and its serene, low-lying architecture is considered a masterpiece of traditional Korean space. Tensions escalated last year when the Seoul city government raised the maximum permitted building height in Sewoon District 4 from 71.9 meters—a limit agreed upon with heritage officials in 2018—to 145 meters, sparking fierce debate over whether high-rise towers would compromise Jongmyo's visual integrity and even threaten its UNESCO World Heritage status.
Sponsored · Ad