Culture & Life Yonhap News Culture · 2026-11-11

Decades After North Korean Abduction, Returning Fishermen Demand State Accountability for Failing to Protect Them

Key Points
  • Surviving fishermen abducted by North Korea in 1971 and repatriated in 1972 have filed an official petition with the Truth and Reconciliation Commission to investigate the South Korean government's fa
  • The action comes after an appellate court rejected the victims' state compensation claims, ruling that maritime defense limitations at the time did not constitute a breach of the state's duty to prote
  • While the state's post-repatriation torture and wrongful surveillance of returned fishermen were officially recognized in 2023, survivors are continuing their fight to erase longstanding societal stig
Summary In a poignant reminder of South Korea’s Cold War legacy, a group of surviving fishermen who were abducted by North Korea in the 1970s and later returned home have formally petitioned the Truth and Reconciliation Commission to investigate whether the South Korean government violated its constitutional duty to protect its citizens. Between August and October 1971, several fishing boats—including the vessel Seungun-ho—were seized by North Korean patrol craft in the East Sea while conducting routine fishing operations. The crew members were held captive in North Korea before being repatriated in September 1972. However, returning home did not mark the end of their ordeal. During the Cold War era, authoritarian South Korean regimes frequently treated returning abductees not as victims of geopolitical aggression, but as suspected communist spies. In 2023, the Second Truth and Reconciliation Commission officially recognized that these fishermen suffered severe human rights violations upon their return, including illegal detention, systematic torture, and intrusive state surveillance. Yet, the legal and moral battle remains unresolved. While the state violence following their return was acknowledged, recent court decisions have largely shielded the state from financial liability. In September, the Chuncheon bench of the Seoul High Court dismissed state compensation claims filed by victims and their families, ruling that South Korea’s maritime defense capabilities at the time made it difficult to conclude that the government breached its duty of care. Seeking to break this legal impasse, civic groups representing the fishermen and public-interest legal teams filed a new investigation request on November 11 outside the Commission’s headquarters in Seoul. They argue that prior investigations overlooked critical questions: What intelligence did the state possess regarding the danger at sea? What maritime security or patrol measures were in place? And why did naval authorities fail to intervene or rescue the vessels despite repeated previous abductions? As legal counsel Choi Jung-kyu pointed out, lingering social prejudice has often blamed the fishermen for allegedly venturing too far into hazardous waters. By demanding an official review into the state's failure to safeguard its citizens, the aging survivors are urging the truth commission to answer a question that has haunted them for over five decades: "Where was the state when we were being taken?"
Sponsored · Ad