Other SBS Sports · 6d ago

Fact Check: Does China Really Account for Up to 40% of Nvidia's Revenue Through Illicit Diversion?

Key Points
  • Viral online claims alleged that diverted AI chip shipments to China account for 20% to 40% of Nvidia's total revenue amid videos showing repurposed hardware.
  • Korean media fact-checked the claim and found the viral 20-40% figure originated from a short-seller report based on an unverified anonymous interview that conflated legal China-linked services with i
  • While U.S. authorities have cracked down on multiple third-country smuggling conduits, analytical estimates place illicit offshore revenue closer to 4%, debunking the exaggerated viral figures.
Summary A circulating viral clip on Chinese social media showing the disassembly and reassembly of graphics cards—purportedly modified so that advanced chips can be repurposed to train Large Language Models (LLMs)—has triggered a major international debate over how U.S. artificial intelligence hardware reaches China despite strict export restrictions. Along with personal controversies surrounding Nvidia leadership, rumors quickly escalated online claiming that illicit, diverted shipments to China make up between 20% to as much as 40% of Nvidia's total revenue. SBS's investigative fact-checking desk, 'Fact is' (Sasil-eun), conducted a deep dive into company filings, financial disclosures, and industry research to evaluate whether there is any substantive ground for these explosive figures. The investigation revealed that Nvidia books geographic revenue based on customer headquarters rather than the final operational destination of the hardware. Consequently, if chips are purchased by entities headquartered in the U.S. or Southeast Asia and later routed elsewhere, official regional breakdowns do not capture these indirect flows. Tracing the viral '20% to 40%' figure, the report identified its origin in a 40-page May report published by Culper Research, a short-selling investment research firm. The report cited an interview with an anonymous former executive alleging that 20% to 40% of Nvidia's data center business remains tied to the Chinese ecosystem. However, context indicates this estimate lumped together all China-linked operations—such as unrestricted cloud services—rather than specifically verifying illegal smuggled goods. In contrast, institutional research firm New Street Research estimated Nvidia's illicit or diverted China-linked revenue at roughly $15 billion, or around 4% of total sales. While the U.S. Department of Justice has officially announced at least three separate enforcement actions this year involving schemes where intermediaries in third countries were used to obscure shipments destined for China, the Korean fact-checkers concluded that claims citing 20% to 40% of Nvidia's overall revenue as illegal backchannel exports lack credible verification. With ongoing inquiries and investigations underway, South Korean tech analysts and media continue to closely monitor the story due to its vast implications for the global semiconductor supply chain.
Sponsored · Ad