Culture & Life Yonhap News Culture · 2026-10-19

Authentic Masterpieces or Forgeries? National Museum Chief Defends Rare Medieval Korean Paintings on US Display

Key Points
  • National Museum of Korea Director Yu Hong-june strongly refuted claims during a parliamentary audit that rare 'Siwangdo' paintings loaned for an exhibition in the United States are Japanese commercial
  • The debate has attracted significant attention in South Korea as a prominent Buddhist art scholar previously raised questions over their authenticity, while museum authorities affirmed they are widely
  • 'Siwangdo' depicts the ten kings who govern the Buddhist afterlife, and the current showcase in Cleveland reunites all ten dispersed 14th-century scrolls from collections across the US, Korea, and Jap
Summary A high-profile exhibition showcasing rare medieval Korean Buddhist artwork in the United States has found itself at the center of an intense authenticity debate. During an annual parliamentary audit by the National Assembly's Culture, Sports, and Tourism Committee, Yu Hong-june, the director of the National Museum of Korea, firmly dismissed allegations that three paintings of the "Ten Kings of Hell" (Siwangdo) loaned to the Cleveland Museum of Art might be commercial forgeries made in Japan. The controversy arose after Representative Lee Jeong-mun raised concerns stemming from claims by Jeong Woo-taek, an emeritus professor at Dongguk University and a prominent scholar of rare Goryeo-era Buddhist paintings. Professor Jeong suggested that the works could be Japanese-made commercial counterfeits. In response, Director Yu countered that this assertion was merely a personal opinion, stating unequivocally that the pieces are authentic and not forgeries. Yu noted that components of this fragmented set are preserved across prestigious global institutions, including Harvard University's Arthur M. Sackler Museum, the Cleveland Museum of Art, and collections in Japan, and are widely accepted as genuine by the broader academic community. While acknowledging ongoing scholarly discussions over whether their exact origin is the Korean Goryeo Dynasty or China's Yuan Dynasty, the National Museum maintains that the works are historically authentic and currently catalogs them as presumed late Goryeo artifacts. The artwork in question forms part of a landmark exhibition at the Cleveland Museum of Art titled "The Ten Kings of Hell: Medieval Korea's Afterlife," which reunites all ten hanging scrolls believed to have been produced in the 14th century. "Siwangdo" refers to traditional Buddhist paintings depicting the ten underworld kings who judge the souls of the deceased, guiding them through various purgatories toward retribution or rebirth. This specific set was once owned by Harry Packard (1914–1991), a well-known collector of Asian art, and was subsequently dispersed across different venues, including the Honolulu Museum of Art, the Denver Art Museum, and institutions in South Korea and Japan. Art historians and cultural observers have hailed the Cleveland exhibition as an exceptional milestone in Korean art history, as it marks the first time these scattered 14th-century masterpieces have been reunited in a single hall. Despite the academic debate surrounding their regional origin and recent questions raised in parliament, the exhibition highlights the profound artistic legacy and spiritual imagination of medieval Korea's Buddhist culture on the global stage.
Sponsored · Ad